NJEA members deliver 112,000 petition signatures calling for pension justice

Urge legislators and governor to eliminate tiered system to strengthen schools

Trenton – More than 100 NJEA members gathered in Trenton today to deliver boxes of signed petitions to Gov. Phil Murphy, Senate President Nicholas Scutari and Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin calling on them to support, pass and sign A5158/S3998 and A5160/S3997 during the current legislative session. Those bills would collapse the current tiers in TPAF and PERS and return all members of those plans to Tier 1. More than 112,000 NJEA members personally signed those petitions.

DSC00943 copy

New Jersey began tiering its pension system in 2007, but the process accelerated under former Gov. Chris Christie, who signed legislation in 2011 that left public employees paying $15 toward their pensions for every $1 contributed by the state. Additionally, by raising the retirement age to 65, Tier 5 requires many new college graduates entering public education to work for up to 43 years to be able to collect their pensions without crippling penalties. As a result, New Jersey schools are facing a critical shortage of teachers and other essential staff positions as highly qualified educators leave for other fields or decide not to enter the profession in the first place.

At an afternoon press conference highlighting the bills, NJEA President Steve Beatty emphasized the inequity created by that tiered system. “Ever since 2007, but especially since 2011, New Jersey’s pension system has been designed to create haves and have nots,” said Beatty. “It’s been set up so that some people in our profession have a promise of retirement security and others have to wonder whether they can stay in public education at all.”

He continued, “A bad pension system doesn’t just hurt our members. It hurts the students we all care so much about, because every year we are losing talented educators who love the work they do but know they cannot afford to stay for a whole career. And it’s stopping others from entering the profession in the first place. And every time a talented person leaves our schools for another profession – or every time a promising college student chooses another major – our public school students pay the price.”

Assemblywoman Verlina Reynolds-Jackson (D-Mercer/Hunterdon), the prime sponsor of the bills in the Assembly, highlighted the importance of passing them. “I stand behind these bills because they are good for students, good for New Jersey families and good for the dedicated educators of our state,” said Reynolds-Jackson. “When NJEA members asked me to sponsor this legislation, I was proud to do so because I know that the work they do every day makes a difference in the lives of students. These bills will make our state an even better place to live, work and raise a family.”

Assemblywoman Luanne Peterpaul (D-Monmouth) also spoke about her belief in the importance of passing the bills. “When our pension system began, New Jersey teachers and educational support professionals had a promise that they would be able to retire with a security and dignity,” said Peterpaul. “Then that promise was broken. We need to restore it. This is about pension justice, so I am proud to join Assemblywoman Reynolds-Jackson to support our great educators and work to pass these important bills.”

Sen. Linda Greenstein (D-Mercer/Middlesex), the prime sponsor of the bills in the Senate, explained her support of the legislation. “By consolidating pension tiers and expanding eligibility to the next generation of teachers and public employees, we are taking a meaningful step toward fairness and stability in our state retirement systems,” said Sen. Greenstein. “These bills will ensure that state employees and educators, who have devoted their lives to serving communities across New Jersey, can access the greater benefits associated with Tier 1 and have a real path to financial security in their retirement.”

Several NJEA members spoke at the press conference and shared their experiences working in a tiered pension system as well.

Sharon Ortiz, a veteran West Orange teacher who is in Tier 1, addressed the harm done to students because her newer colleagues have been forced into inferior pension tiers. “I’m here for my Tier 5 colleagues who must decide every year whether they can afford to stay in a profession that no longer offers true security or dignity in retirement,” said Ortiz. “Our early-career educators are every bit as capable and committed. Despite my longer tenure, I look up to their creativity, energy and professionalism. They are an invaluable asset to our students and strengthen our entire educational community. Yet we are losing too many of them because we can’t provide the stability they deserve. Many of my younger colleagues are moving to other professions—not because they don’t love the work or our students, but because they need to support their families and secure their futures.”

James Frazier, a security officer and longtime union leader from Union Township, talked about the particular harm done to lower-paid educational support professionals. “This tiered pension system in New Jersey is failing the very people who keep our schools running,” said Frazier. “Educational Support Professionals—bus drivers, paraprofessionals, secretaries, custodians, cafeteria staff—are the backbone of every district in this state. Yet the tiered system tells them their service is worth less simply because they started later. It creates divisions, destabilizes the workforce and sends a message that their dedication is somehow discounted. That is unacceptable.”

Kerri Colletto, a mid-career teacher in Edison, highlighted the fundamental inequity of determining someone’s financial future by their date of hire. “I’m one of a tiny number of educators in Tier 4. If I was hired just 4 months earlier, I’d be in Tier 3, with a much better pension. If I was hired just 10 months later, I’d be in Tier 5, with a much, much worse pension,” said Coletto. “Tell me how it makes any sense that those few months have such a huge impact on my whole life?  I’m not a worse teacher than the people hired before me.  I don’t work harder than the people hired after me. We all went to college to get into this profession. We all care for our students. We all spend evenings and weekends grading papers and coming up with creative lessons to keep our students engaged. But we don’t all have the same retirement security. And for some of us – especially my Tier 5 colleagues – that might be what keeps us from staying as long as we want to.”

In addition to delivering the petitions, the NJEA members who came to Trenton spent the day in the Statehouse speaking to legislators of both parties in both houses about the critical importance of passing sign A5158/S3998 and A5160/S3997 to preserve the quality of New Jersey’s public schools for current and future students.

Tags: